I like the colored pika but they are both cute.

awww so cute : ) i like the old one more, ´cause i think the old games were much better than the new games. : ) they´re sooo cute!

that is awesome

plz hav a look at my gallery and tell me wat u think.
p.s AWESOME PIC!!! :)

das is echt süß!ich mag beide pikas.hab selbst pokemon gelb(ganz schön alt ;D)gezockt.und ich sag dir:damals musstest du mit lv.100 durch die pkm-liga.

i love skinny cute pika but i love all the gba pokemon. 1 - 3 gen

Old Pika: Why are you so full of color?
New Pika: Why are you so chubby?

Ich hatte mal rot!(mein erstes Pokemon-Spiel!)Ich hab da mit einem Pika lv.100 die ganze Liga durchgehauen! XD

wann kommt denn das story-bild?

Ich find den neuen süßer ;3
Krieg ich deinen FC? ;D
Mein FC: Bild, Pikachu mit Deutschlandflagge

der neue sieht klasse aus x3 aber der alte hat auch seinen charme, ich hab pokemon blau das war awesome damals :D

Pika-new is more cute =)

haa! funny :D both are cute

Fat Pikachu is more charming. Skinny looks kinda unnatural, since mice irl tend to look kinda tubby.

exelent, visit my gallery

Pikachu is Pikachu, no matter what his weight!

Pikachu. One from old times,chubby,black n white,game boy,and in Kanto. The other one is from the new times,skinny,color,DS,and in Unova. Both are Awsome in there own ways. (Wise words of the day).

The way i see it is, anything old that has been improved over the years was just a prototype for today's best. So, back then pikachu was as cool as the current one is to us now. i like retro and modern things :]

Old One :)

It's obviouse the fat, chubby one is waaay more epic. :P I mean seriously, look at him... Epic...

old looks better to me. miss the belly :(

bothe are grate I like pokemon from anytime or gen.

I prefure classic Pikachu because he's more plump. If any one noticed most classic characters are small and pudgey but when they tern modern they get tall and skinny for example Mario, Sonic, exedera..

i new pikachu is cuter and the old pikachu is kinda fat

i cant decide between them....the pokemon games are just so awesome!!

see my gallery especially my metaknight

I prefer the yellow pika.

awesome! nice idea!
if you want look my pokemon

Old pikachus were fat... they must have been exercising over the years XD

just freakin' awesome!

pika-new! I choose you!

game boy or nintendo(pika old or pika new?)?. nintendo(pika new),obviously.sorry pika old!

To me it doesn't matter, both Pikachu's are cute, and to me they are the same, because I played the classic and the new one and they can learn the same moves, to me apperance doesn't matter it's whats inside that counts.

well pikachu now always sits on ash's shoulders and back then he was so fat maybe thats why he followed him instead just kidding i like them both

the newer 1! ^u^

Both!!! >:D

I remember when I first played Pokemon: Pikachu was so cute. Now, despite all the alterations, Pikachu remains the icon of Pokemon.

Old one. I am NOT a fan of this Pikachu of today.