The Gray In The World by BiniBean

AU: Where when Twilight is sent into the other timelines by Starlight stopping the rainboom, the first one is different, its a world were Celestia was forced to give up the throne.

(Episode: The Cutie Re-Mark, Part 1 + 2)

(Small story in comments to avoid cluttering it up over here)

#MyLittlePony #MLP #TwilightSparkle #PrincessCelestia #Alicorn #AU #Gray #Dark #Spike #Forest #EverfreeForest

(Also Sonarpen is broken, so my lineart will look strange for a while and pics will slow down since I got job, college and a broken sonarpen that I hate rn.)

Comments
9+
share
like
used tools icons

painting stats

painted on a Nintendo Switch
31 Jan, 2023, 4:56 am
03:46

Comments

BiniBean

31 Jan, 2023, 4:58 am

STORY:

"I will not help you." The older alicorn, whom Twilight had never seen in such awful condition snapped at her with an unnaturally harsh tone of voice as Spike and Twilight followed the unknown Celestia down one of the long overgrown paths deep in the Everfree Forest.

"B-But Starlight Glimmer caused this! She has put Equestria in this state! Don't you care about what happens to Equestria? To anypony?" Twilight begged with anger boiling to the surface as she spat out her last words. Spike followed beside her, unsure of what to add as they continued on. Celestia paused as she considered the question before answering slowly. Making sure her words would not be left on deaf ears.

"This world is not the one you know. In this world, my subjects abandoned me. I gave them everything I had, I...I..." Celestia struggled to continue before her own anger flared in her eyes of dark memories. "I couldn't find the element bearers to release my sister from Nightmare Moon, so...when she returned...I had to end her. Permanently. All for them. All for their precious needs. But, as thanks for saving their sorry souls, they revoked my title and threw me away. They banished me from my own home. So no, Twilight Sparkle. I don't have to care about anypony, I have already given all I have. There is nothing left to give."

thecrazynoodlelady

31 Jan, 2023, 5:25 pm

i love this AU gl with ur job and college btw

BiniBean

31 Jan, 2023, 6:35 pm

@thecrazynoodlelady

Thank you :)

LooneyWizard

01 Feb, 2023, 1:46 am

@BiniBean
Ah, the fallen hero... Everybody has done a rendition of this one at least once.

LooneyWizard

01 Feb, 2023, 4:14 am

@BiniBean
Not that that's a bad thing.

BiniBean

01 Feb, 2023, 4:33 am

@LooneyWizard

I find those sorts of stories, mostly for mlp, interesting concepts :)

LooneyWizard

01 Feb, 2023, 5:17 am

@Binibean
Any concept for a fallen hero, whether it be MLP or not, is always an interesting one. Mainly it's because of how they got there, where they went wrong and if redemption is possible.

BiniBean

01 Feb, 2023, 5:34 am

@LooneyWizard

I agree with that!

Dragon_n00dle

02 Feb, 2023, 3:52 am

you're a great artist and storyteller!

BiniBean

02 Feb, 2023, 4:04 am

@Bellanoodle
Thank you!

Please login to leave comments

delete comment?

just delete
delete comment and prevent this user from commenting on your paintings
report as inappropriate

English

Japanese