Aqua ComiContest Results by Gills

Aye! This contest has ended!
Let me say right now to those who entered, you guys all did great, and I thank you for your entries. I enjoyed reading them!

I say you all won. And you all deserve to be rewarded in some way! However, to not be boring, I've talled an overall winner...

The score was composed by Comedy, Detail, Expression, Clean, Creative, Dialog, Fluidity, and Backgrounds.

The one with the highest score is...

@Super Yoshi!

Congratulations!

(continued

#AquaTeam
#AquaComiContest

Comments
9+
share
like
used tools icons

painting stats

painted on a Nintendo 3DS
18 Feb, 2016, 8:36 pm
00:22

Comments

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 8:39 pm

^ran outta space there xD

So, congratulations @Super Yoshi! I think yours was very good and had a comical sense that rooted to the Aqua's goal. You had full backgrounds and a sense of enviroment that made the comic feel live. The dialog was quiet clean, however I had to deduct a point because you had Giru say "possible" when I think you meant to say "possibly"... But you won anyway so congrats :D

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 8:43 pm

Now, @Kikloaxer's was also funny and had an unexpected plot. In expression, Kik's face in the "first" panel seemed believable (which is good!). However, it took a second to read it because it read from the right panel, to the left, then down, which is common in manga but it doesn't note this in the desc so it took a second, thankfully it was only a matter between the first two panels so it's okay.

Also, inclusion of Fire Emblem, I like that. xD

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 8:50 pm

Truth be told, I actually liked @Time Paladin's as a comic itself more than Super Yoshi's, however SY's won by score and so I decided @Time Paladin's was put in at second place.

The character expression was very good, and the inclusion of other Aqua members was a nice touch. The dialog was really, really clean, and I think it was the best written, but I had to deduct a point because some was a bit too small, and I know I can read it easily on my 3dsXL, but I do not know how it works for those with the 3ds or 2ds. I noted no errors or misspells, which is a commendment cuz there's a lot of dialog!

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 8:51 pm

^except that it's Scorpomix, not Scorpiomix, that's the only error in your dialog.

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 8:55 pm

Now, Scorpomix's comic was the last to enter, and it had good action in it. There was different backgrounds and it had a good plot to it, and it felt like an action comic, which was nice. Expression was good here, and the Plasma grunt looks terrified xD It was overall creative and had a good plot. Comedy was there too, so good job!

Time Paladin

18 Feb, 2016, 9:03 pm

Congrats to Super Yoshi! ^-^ Yeah, I also felt the text was uneven in my comic. I've been out of practice when it comes to comics. ^-^" Honestly though, I really enjoyed making it, especially since it's my first contribution to Aqua Team. : )

Gills

18 Feb, 2016, 9:14 pm

Also, here's an update to the Crew Manifest and ranks #CrewManifest so please, check it out :b

@Time Paladin, I think your dialog was terrific! Better than mine xD But Colors!3d does have a very high resolution, so it's sad when the words don't come out so clean...

Thank you for entering though! And please check the tag, it involves you, too :b

(btw, you may keep the jacket, matey)

gojakobii

18 Feb, 2016, 9:32 pm

re: well at first I meant it but then I found the strength to draw a person so u dont have to do it

Time Paladin

18 Feb, 2016, 9:36 pm

Yay! I'm official now! ^u^
I plan on doing a more official post soon with my full team. Thanks for letting me keep the jacket btw! XD

MMvoid

18 Feb, 2016, 9:46 pm

aw dang. Oh well. Congrats, @Super Yoshi!

Inkbrush

18 Feb, 2016, 10:26 pm

Hey, congrats to the winners! I took a look at the tag for ones I had missed, and I had a good laugh at a few of them.

(Gah, I wish I'd joined. Curse you school!)

Ace705

18 Feb, 2016, 10:27 pm

Congrats winners! And all of the honrable mentions!

MMvoid

18 Feb, 2016, 10:54 pm

My Favorite was probably Time Paladin's.

Blue-T95

19 Feb, 2016, 1:20 am

Alas, I have ran out of time to complete my entry... but hey, there's always next time I suppose.

I agree that all the entries that did make it are very well done. Congrats mateys!

kiklolaxer

19 Feb, 2016, 2:38 am

Yay! Rank uppp! Congrats to everyone! ^^ Haha, sorry. Right to left for my comics are common. XD

Kenzie Cat

19 Feb, 2016, 5:00 am

Re: Her first initial design in my sketchbook was a pegasus knight :P xD

Gills

19 Feb, 2016, 8:02 am

You all did awesome, and I'm glad you 4 joined in :b I was getting a bit worried it was gonna be between only 2 artists xD

@Super Yoshi, Ahhh that makes way more sense. And it sounds better in your original version too. Too bad the '?' was cut off...

@Scorpomix, Hey, We've needed a ship, may as well fly, too! xD I thought it was a great comic! If it had been a bit cleaner, I think it could've won.

@Kikloaxer, I think I had learned this from you before, but alas, I still read from Left to Right when I see a comic xD

@Time Paladin, Yes! A comic is still considered an entry drawing if it has you in uniform, so it's official! :b

@BlueT-15, Hey! Please finish it, I'd love to see it still! :b

Brisa!450

19 Feb, 2016, 1:46 pm

Congrats to the winners! :D

(oh wait I am magma)
(walks away slowly xD)

Blue-T95

21 Feb, 2016, 8:53 am

Well if you do still want to see it then I guess there's no harm in finishing it. I'll be sure to have it done soon. :D

Please login to leave comments

delete comment?

just delete
delete comment and prevent this user from commenting on your paintings
report as inappropriate

English

Japanese