Miss Creepypasta seemed innocent at first. Her and Muffin played for hours. But a time came when Muffin faced Herobrine once more...
"Herobrine!"
"Ah, it has been too long, my dear pupil." Herobrine threw the knife at Muffin. It scarred her leg. Herobrine teleported to her.
"You know so little about this world, my dear. You could die for want of a little knowledge. But that can all change in a heartbeat-" Herobrine clicked his fingers. They were instantly in a huge arena. "-at a cost."
"What do you want from me?!"
"Oh, only a very little thing - your life and allegiance."
Muffin stiffened. She was scared by Herobrine but didn't want to show it. She knew where she was. She knew knowledge could keep her alive. She swallowed.
"Ok."

Miss Creepypasta hissed in Muffin's ear :"What are you doing?? Trying to get yourself killed??"
"Ssh," whispered Muffin. "Trust me."
Miss C. shook her head regretfully.
"I hate it when she says that."

Then Herobrine attacked Muffin! Miss C. leapt in front of her though, sacrificing her own innocence. She became evil.

Years later...

Muffin had begun to write a diary. She tracked each day of solitude, hard as it was. Entries were short but frequent.
Day 67
Dear Diary,
Still in isolation. I know I can't have any contact with him, but I so wish to see him again... Oh, how I miss those nights among the stars, how I miss those moonlit flights of fantasy. He told such lovely stories. He occupies my mind from dawn to dusk, and he's all I dream about at night. Hiding is pointless, I suppose, but he's so nasty to others... No. I must stay strong. And he must stay safe. Good luck, wherever you are.

Day 80
Dear Diary,
Freedom! He no longer tyrannically rules over Minecraftia! Ah, the smell of fresh air is the greatest thing in my life. I'm telling you, that poky little dungeon is literal torture to a free soul. But now that free soul is actually free! I'm so happy!

Miss C. is happy. I'm glad for her, but I wish we were still friends. He's her friend now.

Muffin never wrote in her diary again after that day.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
End of Chapter 5

awesome =D keep it up!